Explain it: How did the Leaning Tower of Pisa start leaning?

  • SHARE
Explain it

... like I'm 5 years old

The Leaning Tower of Pisa is a world-famous architectural marvel. So how did the tower start leaning? Simply put, it all began during its construction. The tower was built on a foundation of soft, unstable soil which was not strong enough to support the weight of the structure. As more and more levels were added, the weight of the tower caused it to sink into the ground on one side, resulting in the characteristic tilt we see today.

Imagine you're building a sandcastle on the beach. If you pile too much sand on one side, that side will collapse under the weight. The same thing happened with the Leaning Tower of Pisa - too much weight on soft ground caused it to lean.

Explain it

... like I'm in College

Let's delve a little deeper into the Leaning Tower of Pisa. The tower's construction began in 1173, and it was built in three stages over a period of 199 years. The foundation was laid on a dense layer of clay, fine sand, and shells, which is known as marine clay. This type of soil is known to be susceptible to compression under heavy loads, especially when water is present.

Because of wars and other political reasons, construction was halted several times, which ironically, helped the tower. If the tower was built continuously, the soft soil wouldn't have had the time to settle and compact under the weight of the tower, leading to a possible collapse.

Think of it like slowly filling a bucket with water. If you fill it too quickly, the water will spill out. But if you add the water gradually, the bucket will have time to adjust.

EXPLAIN IT with

To visualize this with Lego bricks, imagine building a tower on a base of soft, squishy Play-Doh instead of a hard Lego base. As you add more bricks, the weight of your Lego tower presses down on the Play-Doh. If the Play-Doh is too soft or too wet, it will begin to deform under the weight, causing your Lego tower to lean to one side.

In the case of the Leaning Tower of Pisa, the Play-Doh represents the soft, weak soil, and the Lego bricks represent the weight of the stone used to build the tower. Despite the lean, the tower stands strong, much like your Lego tower would, demonstrating the marvel of medieval engineering.

Just like your Lego tower on Play-Doh, the Leaning Tower of Pisa managed to stand despite its lean because of the skill and adjustments made by the engineers and builders of the time.

Explain it

... like I'm an expert

Now, let's get technical. The foundation of the Leaning Tower of Pisa is only three meters deep, which is shallow considering the tower's height and weight. The subsoil is composed of silt and clay layers with lenses of sand. The crucial factor that contributed to the inclination of the tower was the presence of a weak, compressible stratum of marine clay, known as "Pisa Clay".

The differential settlement became evident when the second floor was completed, and despite attempts to correct the tilt by adjusting the design, the inclination continued. This phenomenon, known as geotechnical failure, is a classic example of the importance of understanding soil mechanics in construction.

It's like trying to balance a pencil on a sponge. The pencil represents the tower and the sponge, the soft soil. No matter how you adjust the pencil, it will tilt because the sponge is not firm enough to hold it upright.

  • SHARE